Yes, I know – five blog posts about a phone within two weeks may be too much for most readers, but some people have asked me how I like my new mobile phone – the Motorola DEFY – so I went on and compiled a review on it. In German, for Amazon.de.
Don’t speak German? Then read on….
The part where you’ll lose your readers is probably where you start talking about how good product xyz is. There are 163 reviews on Amazon.de about this particular phone at the moment, and almost all reviews describe how great this phone is. So I went on and tried to focus on the disadvantages of the Motorola Defy – which I think are important facts when you’re about to invest some money in a new phone.
It’s an incomplete list, things (especially some software issues) are subject to change, we’re talking about a Motorola Defy in mid February 2011. Also, I started as an Android n00b (when I got this phone a week ago).
1. The micro-USB port is at the side of the devices, so you’ll have troubles finding a suitable docking station. I’ve built my own, but the device still acts up when inserted into the docking station, even with the latest (unofficial) software. Plus the port is covered by a piece of plastics which needs to be removed (and is fixed to the body of the phone) – thus: a docking station will always have to provide enough room for this flap. It’s still better than the flaps on the Nokia phones I’ve reviewed in the past and of course helps protect the phone from water and dust.
2. There’s no specialised accessory available as of yet except for the usual suspects such as car chargers, (passive) car mounts, display and body covers. No docking station, no headphones, no spare parts. And this although the phone has sold quite well over the last few months. Where are all these Chinese manufacturers when you need them? Or could this be related to the nasty docking station issue I’ve experienced on my Defy (phone switches into flight mode, starts media player)? Or is that just a “media dock”-mode? Hmm.
Moto DEFY car mount menu (very nice!)
Moto DEFY media dock menu (before it started acting up…?!).
opened Motorola DEFY headset (hint: iPhone headsets do work)
tip = L // 2nd ring = R // 3rd ring = M- // sleeve = M+
3. The ear speaker problem a lot of (not all, but many) Moto Defys came with is due to low quality speakers and should have been avoided by quality management. Especially since the rest of the phone is top-notch Motorola quality. The Sony K770 (mobile phone) is said to be a resource for alternative speakers….
4. The camera. I believe that the camera module inside the phone is capable of doing much more than what we see as end results. The picture quality is far away from the likes of Nokia N95, N82 or even N8 (it’s just a simple 5mpx module after all) and when I installed new firmware on the phone, I realized how much better this camera can be. Really, an upgrade of the camera software should be recommended to Motorola.
How about these two totally unrelated macro sample shots? (taken with the phone on Android 2.2)
5. Motorola currently ships this phone with Android 2.1. I am using a retail version which means any upgrade of the internal firmware isn’t possible over-the-air (OTA), but instead only via a Motorola software on my computer. So I upgraded it from version 2.2.1 to 2.5.1 (both within Android 2.1) and still had some nasty bugs on it like folder names that disappeared after rebooting the phone, or missing lock screens after pressing the main button. Also, I wasn’t using Motorola’s own Android skin “Motoblur”, so I can’t remark on that one. Anyways, after experiencing all these bugs, I decided to flash it with a leaked BLURless ROM from Orange Poland (!) to Android 2.2. What you actually do is a full wipe of all user data on the phone, install the new ROM, do another full wipe and remove some Orange default settings. It’s an automated process that will certainly kill any warranty on the phone, so you should only do it if you know what to do. I didn’t, but I tried it nevertheless and was really surprised:
Motorola Defy + Android 2.2 – Motoblur = AWESOME!
Don’t get me wrong, this preliminary BETA via Orange Poland still has some bugs, but Motorola would be well advised to change their policy on this Motoblur thing and have it removed, or only make it available upon request. Or keep it for business customers who need a closed environment. Not because Motoblur is bad – it isn’t – but because the development and adjustment of Motoblur slows down the entire process for future Android releases on the phone. Seriously, you can not ship a brand new phone (released to the market in Nov. 2010) with Android 2.1 while the competition already has 2.3 and while I can get 2.2 on any cheaper 100€ Android device (ZTE, Huawei, etc.).
Else, I think the Motorola Defy is a great phone and is unique enough to remain on the market (even with Android 2.1!) for a very long time.
Another detail I eventually also realized: you’ll need to register a credit card with Google to buy software on their Android market. On Apple iTunes, there are vouchers available for purchase in our local supermarket. So it’s not only the great UI, simplicity of the iPhone or good apps that made the Apple iPhone dominate the market, but also this ecosystem called iTunes (compared to other like Android market) that contributed to the success of the iPhone. You’ll read about such things and think: “yeah, of course…”, but then when you are charged extra fees on your CC because it was used on Google checkout (US <=> Germany), you’ll quickly understand that some things are smarter with iTunes for a very good reason. This, however, isn’t related to the phone, but to all Android devices.
So…. does the Motorola Defy suck? – NO, of course not.
5 thoughts on “Five reasons why the Motorola Defy sucks (not really)”
Very Nice approach to a review. People tend to get caught up in the awesomeness of this or that new thing they just purchased, as a justification to themselves that the choice to buy the product was the right one..
Would like a link to the ROM you use, and to know more about the glitches you see with this version. Other than that a very nice review. Vielen Dank!
Thx! I’ve used the (German) tutorial from this link: http://www.android-hilfe.de/root-hacking-modding-fuer-motorola-defy/76504-android-build-3-4-2-131-orange-en-pl.html, the ROM is 3.4.2-131.Orange.en.PL, which is a deblured ROM in use with Orange network in Poland. No glitches so far, at least not the same ones I had with Android 2.1. Hope this helps!
Super , Thanks !! How’s the battery life because Android phones are not that good when it comes to a good long lasting battery? I dont really care about the quality of camera on phones and quite frankly no smartphone is yet to come out with a killer camera on their phone. The ear-piece problme was the biggest problem for Defy and Motorola, according to reports, has fixed this from Dec’ 2010 manufacturing date. This is identified by a blue dot inside (or maybe outside on the label) the phone under the battery door near camera with marking BT/BF or BT33. Suggest you buy one post Jan’2011 production date.
@Bob: mine is from Nov. 2010 and still hasn’t produced the faulty ear piece problem. But since I bought mine as a 2nd hand device (“demo”, not sure if refurbished because the dealer didn’t do this), I don’t know if mine had already been repaired. I also read that the production date is NOT an indicator because there are users on different fora who complain about this ear piece problem even though they are using one from the latest charge.
Re: battery life. It could be better. I am using JuiceDefencer (app) and flashed a beta Android 2.2.1, but the battery only lasts for 1,5 days. Already using all known & popular battery saving settings, coupled with this app.
Thanks! So although Motorola has fixed all issues the purchaser needs to be prepared for a faulty piece if he/she is unlucky enough to get one and head back to the service centre. I’ll keep that in mind cuz I am certainly going to buy the Defy very soon as soon as I know about the 2.2 upgrade.
Battery: Am not surprised to know that the battery isn’t all that great but still 1,5 days isn’t bad. Ofcourse if one uses it for music + apps + 3G hotspot then thats a different story. I guess the official 2.2 upgrade will be out very soon. SFR France has confirmed the date as April ‘end.
Comments are closed.